Or were we looking for evidence that Christians have souls but atheists don't? Oooh I'm lost.

No we were discussing ecu's question
"i did feel very conscious how disparaging supercilious and smug and very annoying religious people can be in believing they are better than anyone else... and i really did not want to go down that road...
but a question:.... are atheists better than religious people on the goodness front? or visa versa?"
kind people are kind people - never mind whether they have souls or Christian views, and nobody is better than anyone else on that front.